Tuesday, April 27, 2010
RR 4
I really enjoyed reading the Blackwater essay for a couple reasons. I really like the way the write uses a long quote at the beginning of the paper. This quote sets a very solemn tone but at the same time is displaying very important and relevant information. I am always a fan of playing with the format of an essay. In high school, we were taught to have a little more freedom from the standard intro, 3 body paragraphs, conclusion format. The way this writer presents the essay catches my attention right off the bat and keeps it that way because of the use of shorter and longer paragraphs, along with adding longer quotes in the middle. In addition to the formatting, the paper was very well written (But they need to use tab instead of a few spaces in the beginning of each paragraph, how were points not marked off for that?). The writer did a great job of filling out every piece of information and painting a picture that is easy to understand. I didn't have any prior knowledge of this task force so I'm also grateful that Kaitlin assigned this reading. Anyways, the one down part to this paper is that it kind of has a dark tone, but i'll get over it. Great work to whoever wrote it!
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
i did not think it was that good, it sounded like a news paper article or a report, it was too much outside information, the author did not really emphasized the quotes or the info given.
ReplyDeleteI don't know why back in my day teachers emphasized the five paragraph format so much since no one in academia uses it. Any topic that you write about college merits something of about 10 or 15 fat paragraphs, at least. This guy definitely took a different approach and it results in really good paper, but not just for that reason alone. AS for it being dark, I generally prefer the darker papers because they have a chance of shocking me and telling me something that I didn't know or was too afraid to learn about.
ReplyDeleteI kinda agree with Tatiana. The essay was well written, I give it that. And it sounded like the writer put a lot of effort into researching. But i actually didn't like the style too much. It was boring to me...but then again, maybe i just didn't like that research topic and you did.
ReplyDeleteI personally enjoyed the essay as well, but I remember having the hook lose hold with the essay's progression. I also thought that it wasn't very argumentative. I don't mean confrontational, I mean that I can't remember a persuasive point in the piece. It seemed to just lay out the facts without actively proving a point.
ReplyDeleteaw, glad to hear that you are really enjoying all the readings! I agree with you on that the essay is well written and constructed and stylish and i can see why some people would think that it is too stylish. I agree that it was a little dull for me but eventually got better. I do agree that it could have been a little bit more argumentative.
ReplyDelete